ADU vs. Addition: Which One Adds More Value to Your Property?

Main Content

With sky-high home prices and ever-increasing demand for flexible living space, Los Angeles homeowners are looking for ways to boost both functionality and property value. Two of the most popular options? Building an ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) or adding square footage to the main house.

Both options can add significant value—but they serve different purposes, come with different costs, and are subject to different zoning rules. Here's how to decide which one makes more sense for your property, your lifestyle, and your bottom line.

What’s the Difference?

ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit): A detached or attached secondary home on the same lot—often with its own kitchen, entrance, and bathroom. Think: guest house, rental unit, or aging-in-place suite.
Addition: Square footage added directly to the primary residence—like a new bedroom, expanded kitchen, or second-story build-out.

Cost Comparison

Project Type	Average Cost in LA	Price Range
ADU (Detached)	$100,000 – $300,000	Varies by size/design
Addition	$150,000 – $350,000	~$400–$500 per sq.ft.

ADU Pros: Potential rental income offsets cost. Adds a self-contained unit that can be separately metered.
Addition Pros: Lower permitting complexity in some areas. Seamlessly expands your existing home.

Important: ADU costs can be higher upfront due to separate plumbing, kitchen, and structural needs—but the ROI can be stronger if used as a rental.

Which Adds More Value?

It depends on your property goals:

ADU:
✅ Increases property value and income potential
✅ Appeals to investors, multigenerational families, and buyers seeking rental flexibility
✅ Often appraised as a “second unit” in comps
Addition:
✅ Increases the livable square footage of the main home
✅ Great if you’re planning to stay and need more space (but no separate rental needed)
✅ Valuation is more straightforward—but ROI varies based on room type (bedroom > bonus room)

In general:

An ADU offers higher ROI if you plan to rent or resell to a buyer looking for income potential.
An addition offers more comfort if you want to stay and enjoy the space for yourself.

Zoning & Permit Considerations in LA

ADU:
✅ California law has made it much easier to build ADUs, even in areas previously restricted
✅ Most single-family and multi-family lots qualify
✅ Setbacks, height limits, and size caps vary by zone—generally up to 1,200 sq. ft.
✅ Must have separate kitchen and entrance
Addition:
✅ Requires permits and may face setback or height restrictions
✅ HOA rules and historical designations can limit options
✅ Might trigger additional upgrades (e.g., fire sprinklers, seismic retrofits) depending on scale

Pro Tip: Always check with LADBS or consult a local architect before committing—rules can vary by neighborhood.

Construction Timeline

ADU: 9–12 months from design to completion
Addition: 6–10 months depending on complexity

Keep in mind both projects may require temporary relocation, construction noise, and inspections—but ADUs are often easier to isolate from daily living if built detached.

What’s Right for You?

Goal	Best Option
Maximize long-term ROI	ADU (especially as a rental)
Expand for your own lifestyle	Addition
Add value before selling	Depends on market trends and lot layout
Create multi-gen housing	ADU with privacy

Final Thoughts

In a competitive LA housing market, both ADUs and additions can be powerful ways to increase your property’s livability and value. The right choice depends on your lot, your budget, your goals; and whether you’re adding for family, functionality, or financial return.

Thinking about adding value to your home? Let’s walk your property, discuss zoning, and help you decide which route delivers the most upside in today’s market.